A Second Chance at Happiness : Chapter 4

Seeing him again wasn’t how Anjali had imagined it. Not after all these years.

Not after all those quiet, carefully folded memories she had tucked away like old letters—never thrown, never opened.

And definitely not like this.

There had been no pause in his voice.
No flicker of recognition that carried weight.
No unspoken “I missed you.”

Just—

“Hey, Anjali… it’s been a long time.”

Like she was just another name from a classroom list.
Another face from a blurred past. And she had smiled back.

Of course she had. Because that’s what she had learned to do—be composed, be graceful, be fine.

But inside? Inside, something had shifted.

Not broken… just quietly unsettled.

She hadn’t realized how much of him she had carried all these years.

Not in a dramatic, life-altering way. But in the small things.

In the way certain songs still reminded her of college corridors.
In how she would sometimes wonder, Where would he be now?
In the faint, almost-forgotten warmth of a crush that had never been confessed… never been acknowledged… but had still been real.

At least to her. And maybe that was the problem. It had only been real to her.

When he spoke to her now, casually, politely—like nothing had ever existed between them—
it wasn’t rude. It was… normal. Painfully normal.

And somehow, that hurt more than indifference ever could.

Because indifference would have meant distance.
But this?  This meant absence.

Absence of everything she had once felt.

Absence of the girl she had been around him—softer, lighter, a little more hopeful.

She found herself overthinking every small detail.

Did he really not remember?
Or did it simply never matter enough to remember?

And the answer came quietly, without cruelty—

Yes. Maybe she had been.

And that was Okay..  And yet, beneath that ache, there was something else too.

A quiet acceptance.

A realization that maybe the feelings she had held onto weren’t really about him anymore.

They were about who she had been back then.

The girl who believed in simple things.
In stolen glances meaning something more.

That girl had grown up. Life had happened.. Pain had happened.

And somewhere along the way, she had learned that not every feeling needed closure.

Some were meant to exist only in a certain time… in a certain version of you.

So she smiled again, softer this time—but real.

A comfortable silence settled between them now.

Not heavy. Not awkward.

Just… peaceful.

And for the first time in a long while, Anjali allowed herself to feel it.

Arnav came out of the room and called for her sister. He saw the exchange between Anuj and her and ignored it. 

Both men politely exchanged handshakes.

"Di.. You please go home. You can come back tomorrow with my change of clothes. I will ask Akash to come and take you. I don't want you to drive back home alone. "  

"Jiju.. Its ok, we will drop her home, No need to call anyone. We are going that way only." Mukku replied before Anjali could answer.

Anjali tried to stay in the hospital itself but Arnav did not agree. Finally she agreed to go home.

Anjali had insisted she could manage on her own, but Anuj and Mukku hadn’t really given her a choice. And before she knew it, she was seated in the backseat—with him driving and his sister beside him.

The car ride was supposed to be quiet.

And his sister… was anything but quiet.

“So, Anjali Di..” she turned around excitedly, eyes sparkling with curiosity, “you knew bhai from college, right?”

Anjali blinked, slightly caught off guard. “Yes… we were in the same class.”

“Same class?” she repeated dramatically. “That means you have stories.”

Anuj sighed, already sensing where this was going. “Mukku—”

“Oh please, bhai,” she cut him off, waving a hand dismissively. “You’ve hidden your entire college life from me. Today I finally have a source.”

Anjali couldn’t help the small smile that formed.

“Was he always this serious? Or did he actually have a personality back then?”

Anjali’s eyes flickered to Anuj through the rearview mirror.

He looked… mildly embarrassed.

And somehow, that made something warm stir inside her.

“He wasn’t always serious,” she admitted.

“Oh?” Mukku’s eyes widened. “Details. I need details.”

Anuj groaned. “This is a bad idea.”

Anjali let out a soft laugh, the tension inside her easing just a little.

“He used to talk a lot, actually,” she said.

“Excuse me?” Anuj glanced at her quickly.

Mukku gasped. “No way. This man?” she pointed at him. “Talkative?”

“Very,” Anjali nodded, a hint of mischief slipping into her tone. “Especially during lectures.”

“Traitor,” Anuj muttered under his breath.

Mukku clutched her heart dramatically. “I feel cheated. All these years I thought you were born boring.”

Anjali laughed again—this time more freely.

“And?” Mukku pressed on. “Any embarrassing stories? Please tell me he has at least one.”

Anjali hesitated for a second.

Her mind flickered back—classrooms, shared glances, quiet smiles… moments that had meant so much to her.

But here, in this car, they felt lighter.

Safer.

“There was one time,” she began slowly, “he was so busy talking that he didn’t realize the professor had been standing right behind him for a full minute.”

Mukku burst out laughing. “No!”

“Oh yes,” Anjali nodded, her eyes briefly meeting Anuj’s in the mirror. “And when he finally turned around… I’ve never seen someone go silent so fast.”

Anuj shook his head, a reluctant smile tugging at his lips. “You remember that?”

There was something in his voice.

Not just amusement.

Something softer.

Anjali noticed it.

And for a brief second, her heart responded before she could stop it.

“I remember,” she said quietly.

Mukku, completely oblivious to the shift, grinned. “This is gold. I need more.”

“Absolutely not,” Anuj said firmly. “That’s enough humiliation for one day.”

“Aww,” she pouted, then looked back at Anjali. “You’re coming home with us next time. I need a full college archive.”

Anjali smiled politely. “Let’s see.”

The car slowed as it approached her house.

For a moment, silence settled again—but this time, it wasn’t awkward.

It was… thoughtful.

As the car stopped, Anjali gathered her things.

“Thank you,” she said. “For the ride.”

“Anytime,” Anuj replied.

Mukku beamed. “And next time, I expect more stories!”

Anjali nodded, stepping out of the car.

As she closed the door and took a few steps toward her house, she felt it again—

That strange mix of warmth and ache.

But lighter now.

Because this time, the memories didn’t feel one-sided.

He remembered too.

Maybe not in the same way.

Maybe not with the same depth.

But enough.

And for now…

That was enough.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The room was dim, washed in soft white light and the steady rhythm of the monitor beside her.

Khushi  lay still against the pillows, her face pale but peaceful, a stark contrast to the storm that had raged just hours ago.

The door opened quietly.

Arnav Singh Raizada stepped in. Finally he managed to send everyone else out of the hospital.

For a moment, he didn’t move. Didn’t breathe.

Just… looked at her. As if reassuring himself that she was really there. That she was alive. That he hadn’t lost her.

His hand trembled slightly as he pulled a chair closer to the bed and sat down. Slowly, hesitantly, he reached for her hand.

It felt colder than he liked.

His grip tightened instinctively.

Her fingers twitched in his hold.

Slowly, her eyes fluttered open.

Weak. Disoriented. But searching. for him

And when they found him…

They stilled. For a moment, neither spoke.

“Khushi…”

Her name broke from his lips like a confession.

No arrogance. No anger. No walls.

“I don’t even know where to begin,” he let out a shaky breath, his thumb brushing gently over her knuckles. “There’s so much I’ve said… so much I’ve done…”

His voice faltered.

For a man who always had control, words had never felt this heavy.

“I hurt you,” he whispered, the truth settling between them like something irreversible. “Not once… not in anger… but again and again. And the worst part is—” his voice cracked, “I thought I was right.”

His eyes burned, but he didn’t look away.

“I let my past… my fears… my anger decide who you were. I didn’t even try to see you… not really.”

He bowed his head, pressing her hand to his forehead.

“I accused you… doubted you… punished you for something you never did.”

The silence in the room deepened, broken only by the soft beeping of the monitor—steady, reminding him she was still here… still fighting.

“And even today…” his grip tightened, desperation slipping through, “it took almost losing you for me to understand what you’ve always been to me.”

He finally looked up at her, his eyes filled with something she had rarely seen from him.

Fear.

“I was so close to a life without you,” he whispered. “Do you have any idea what that did to me?”

His voice dropped, almost breaking.

“It destroyed me.”

A tear slipped down, unnoticed.

“I don’t deserve your forgiveness,” he admitted. “I don’t deserve your trust. But I—” he stopped, struggling to steady himself, “I can’t walk away from this… from you… without telling you the truth.”

He leaned closer, his voice soft but unwavering now.

“I love you, Khushi.”

The words lingered in the air, fragile yet powerful.

“I don’t say it enough. I don’t show it the way you deserve. But it’s there… in every breath, every thought, every moment I’m with you.”

His thumb brushed away a strand of hair from her forehead, his touch infinitely gentle.

“And I’m sorry,” he whispered. “Not just for the words… but for the way I made you feel. Alone… when I should have been your strength.”

He closed his eyes briefly, gathering whatever was left of his composure.

“If you give me one chance… just one… I will spend the rest of my life proving that you were never a mistake in my life.”

His voice softened, almost breaking again.

“You were… the only right thing.”

A faint movement.

His breath hitched.

“Khushi…?”

His eyes held hers, full of everything he had just said… and everything he still couldn’t.

“Arnavji…” her voice was barely a whisper.

He leaned forward instantly. “I’m here. I’m right here.”

She studied his face—really studied it.

The tears. The fear. The vulnerability he never let anyone see.

And something inside her softened.

She held his gaze, her eyes glistening.

Then, slowly—very slowly—she tightened her fingers around his.

It wasn’t strong.

But it was enough.

Enough to tell him what words didn’t need to.

His breath left him in a rush, relief flooding through every part of him.

And for the first time, the silence in the room wasn’t heavy. It was healing.

Love,

ST